Scholium Group plc ('Scholium' or the 'Group')

Preliminary Results for the year ended 31 March 2020

This announcement contains inside information for the purposes of Article 7 of regulation 596/2014

Scholium is engaged in the business of rare books, art and collectibles.  Its primary operating subsidiary is Shapero Rare Books which is one of the leading UK dealers trading internationally in rare and antiquarian books and works on paper.   

The Group also trades alongside other third party dealers in the broader arts and collectibles business via its subsidiary, Scholium Trading Limited and deals in and sells by auction stamps and philatelic items through its subsidiary Mayfair Philatelics Limited 

The Board of Scholium is pleased to announce its final results and annual accounts for the year ended 31 March 2020.

Operating Highlights 

·      Revenues up 2.3% to £7.3 million for full financial year

·      The Group's profit before tax was £25k, despite the disruption to activity in March 2020

·      All businesses performed better than in prior financial year

·      Scholium Trading produced good profits with further potential ahead

·      Group has written off its deferred tax asset of £277k due to the adverse impact of Covid-19

·      Group is loss making currently, though sales have improved significantly since end May

Financial Highlights 

A copy of the 2020 Annual Report (including the notice of Annual General Meeting ("AGM") will be sent to shareholders in due course. The Annual Report will also be available on the Company's website in due course. http://scholiumgroup.com

The Company's AGM will be held at 10.30am at 32 St George Street, London W1S 2EA on 30 September 2020.

Jasper Allen, Chairman of Scholium, noted "We are pleased to have achieved a profit before tax of £25k in the year to 31 March 2020 despite the adverse effect of Covid-19. The Group is adapting to the new business environment with higher levels of online activity, the results of which have been encouraging." 

For further information, please contact

Chairman's Statement 

The Group increased revenues by 2.3% to £7.3 million as a result of the improved performance in each of the Group's three separate revenue streams - Shapero Rare Books, Scholium Trading and Mayfair Philatelics.

The Group incurred a small loss in the second half of the financial year due to the adverse impact of Covid-19 in March 2020, normally the Group's busiest trading month, due to the cancellation of the trade fairs.  Pleasingly, despite this loss, the Group achieved a profit before tax for the year to 31 March 2020 of £25,000.

The core business, Shapero Rare Books, had a better year with higher profits than last year. Scholium Trading performed well in the year and delivered a higher profit than the prior year, which was particularly pleasing given its relatively modest stock. Mayfair Philatelics continued to improve, reducing its trading loss compared with the previous year.

The progress made across the Group's three revenue streams is encouraging, and Scholium Trading has interests in some paintings with good potential. Shapero Rare Books continues to be one of the world's leading rare book dealers and has been able to continue to develop its online profile and activities in the first part of this new financial year.

The board has reviewed several acquisition opportunities in each of its three revenue streams during the course of the year but concluded that none were sufficiently profitable on a sustainable basis to pursue. The board is continuing to search for further acquisitions.

The Group remains well capitalised with £9.0 million of stock, £0.3 million in cash and no debt. The Group also has an undrawn overdraft facility available to it. The board recognizes that the Group's trading performance in recent years has not provided the intended returns to shareholders, despite the reduction in the overheads implemented two years ago. Accordingly, the board have concluded that the Group will take advantage of the expiry of the current lease on its premises and is therefore seeking to move to lower cost premises during the current financial year. Costs will also be lower in the current year due to the cancellation of a number of trade fairs that the Group customarily attends.

Results 

Group revenue for the year of £7.3 million (2019: £7.1 million) generated a profit before tax of £25,000 (2019: loss of £13,000). In the light of the adverse impact of Covid-19, the Group has written off all of its deferred tax asset of £277,000, (2019: £nil). The Group therefore recorded a loss after tax of £252,000 for the year to 31 March 2020 (2019: loss £13,000).

Staff 

The Group's operations continue to rely on the hard work and dedication of our employees and I would like to take this opportunity of thanking them again for their contribution and effort during the year. 

Current Trading and Prospects 

Trading conditions have inevitably been difficult since 31 March 2020, and the Group's retail premises remained closed until mid-June. Since re-opening, footfall has been significantly lower than in the previous year. It is the Board's present expectation that the Group will incur a loss in the first half of the year to 30 September 2020 as a result of the disruption from Covid-19. However, the Group's response has been to actively work to increase its online sales of books, prints and stamps and we have been encouraged in recent months by the level of online sales as well as sales created through social media highlights.

Strategic Report 

Strategic Report

This report provides an overview of the Group's strategy and business model; gives a review of the performance of the operating entities and of the financial position at 31 March 2020; and sets out the principal risks to which the Group is exposed. In addition, it comments briefly on the future prospects of the business.  

Principal Activities & Review of the Business 

The Group is engaged in the business of dealing in rare books, fine art and collectibles.  The majority of the business transacted is as a dealer - buying, owning and selling items, either on its own or together with third parties who also deal as principals. The Group also conducts auctions where both its own stock and third party consignments are available for sale.  The Group maintains value from ownership of its stock and generates value through its expertise, astute buying and the profitable sale of stock. 

Shapero Rare Books is the main business of the Group.  It is a leading international dealer in rare and collectible books and works on paper with special expertise in Natural History, Illustrated, Travel and Exploration and Literature. The business also trades as Shapero Modern in modern and contemporary prints and limited editions by established artists.    

Scholium Trading focuses on trading works of art in the wider art market using its own capital and the expertise of a small number of known third party dealers and their client bases.

Mayfair Philatelics is a dealer and auctioneer of stamps with a particular focus on British and Commonwealth stamps. Regular auctions are held in London and at Lingfield, Sussex, where both the company's own stock and third party consignments are sold. It conducted its first online sale in July 2020 with success.

Strategy & Key Objectives 

The Group's strategy is to:

•                   build, either organically or by acquisition, a portfolio of collectibles businesses to enable further diversification of its revenue and profit streams;

•                   attract individuals or teams of specialists in markets complementary to the Group's existing businesses;

•                   optimize working capital in existing businesses to provide funds for new business development; and

•                   continue to develop all its entities by trading alongside other dealers in high value rare and collectible items and by participating in the acquisition for onward sale of large consignments.

The Directors intend, in due course, to provide an attractive level of dividends to shareholders along with stable asset-backed growth driven by the markets in which the Group operates.

Review of the year from continuing operations  

The Group's revenues increased to £7.3m from £7.1m in the prior year due to increased sales in Shapero Rare Books, Scholium Trading. The Group traded profitably for the year, despite a small loss in the second half of the year due to Covid-19 and the consequent reduced activity in March 2020, normally one of the busiest months. The Group's profit before tax for the year to 31 March 2020 was £25k. Revenue increased by 2.3% and gross profit increased by 4.6% compared with the prior year ended 31 March 2019, due mainly to improved margins in Shapero Rare Books.  

Direct costs increased due to the attendance at the Miami print fair and overhead expenses were at similar levels to last year. Central costs, including the costs of the Company's listing on AIM, were marginally higher than the prior year.   

The increase in revenue reflects the higher sales in Shapero Rare Books and Scholium Trading. The Group has written off its deferred tax asset of £277k due to the adverse Covid-19 impact on sales in the current year.

The Group's stock at 31 March 2020 was £8,981k compared with the prior year of £8,657k. Shapero Rare Books had a slightly increased stock level as March sales were curtailed by the onset of restrictions due to Covid 19. Scholium Trading's stock was also slightly higher by comparison with the prior year due to purchases in March. Mayfair Philatelics' stock was slightly below the prior year.

Group cash at 31 March 2020 was £281k, an improvement on the £192k cash in the prior year. The Group's overdraft was utilised during the year in order to manage its working capital requirements.

Key Performance Indicators 

The Group is managed by and reports on a number of key performance indicators (KPIs).  

The current principal KPIs are:

•                   Sales, gross profit and gross margin, profit before tax;

•                   the breadth and distribution of the stock of rare books held by the Group;

•                   stock turnover; and

•                   cash flow.

Group Performance 

The financial information below excludes the application of intragroup management charges. The trading activities, assets and liabilities of Scholium Trading and Mayfair Philatelics were transferred to Shapero Rare Books on 31 March 2020. The Group's subsidiaries therefore all now trade through Shapero Rare Books.

Shapero Rare Books 

Shapero Rare Books (SRB) continued trading profitably during the year ended 31 March 2020. The year's sales were £5,889k, slightly above the prior year's sales of £5,642k and gross profit likewise at £2,293k for the year ended 31 March 2020 compared with the prior year of £2,214k.  

Direct costs including the attendance at fairs, exhibitions, and catalogues increased from £500k in the prior year to £579k in the year to 31 March 2020. This reflected the costs of exhibiting at fairs including the attendance for the first time at Miami in December 2019. Overhead costs decreased marginally from £1,562k in the prior year to £1,556k in the year to 31 March 2020.

SRB therefore recorded a profit before tax of £145k compared with the profit of £140k in the prior year.

Scholium Trading 

Scholium Trading performed well in the year ended 31 March 2020 with a contribution to gross profit of £236k compared to £192k for the prior year. In addition, the current stock includes some interests in paintings with potentially high levels of return.

Mayfair Philatelics 

The year to 31 March 2020 continued the fuller auction programme for Mayfair Philatelics. There were three auctions in each half of the year. The first half loss of £7k (2019:£104k) increased  slightly to £16k  (2019:£46k profit) in the second half, as a result of Covid 19's adverse impact on the March auction at Lingfield. The overall loss for the year was therefore £23k (2019:£58k).

Central Costs

Central costs include the cost of all board members as well as those costs associated with the Group's AIM listing.  The central costs were £299k in the year to 31 March 2020, an increase of £23k from the prior year's total of £276k. These costs include the cost of managing the Group, its audit, tax and professional fees, as well as the costs of maintaining the AIM listing for the Company's shares.

Year ended 31 March 2020 (£'000) 

Year ended 31 March 2019 (£'000) 

Dividend 

The Board does not propose to declare a final dividend for the financial year ended 31 March 2020. 

Principal Risks & Uncertainties 

Supply of rare books, works on paper, prints and stamps and other items  

By definition, rare books and other works on paper, prints and stamps are not commonly available. The availability of fresh stock of such items onto the market is often driven by major life events, such as inheritance, unrecovered debt, divorce or downsizing due to economic malaise. The business of Shapero Rare Books, Scholium Trading and Mayfair Philatelics is reliant upon individual works and collections of works coming onto the market and upon the Group being able to access those business opportunities. There is no guarantee that fresh stock will come onto the market in sufficient quantities to meet the Group's plans for continued growth, or that third parties will choose to consign their items for sale at the Group's auctions.  

When works become available for sale or purchase, such sales are often dealt with privately and discretely and, accordingly, there is no guarantee that the Group's employees will be able to access such business opportunities or to negotiate successfully the purchase of fresh stock coming onto the market or successfully compete for the mandate to auction such items.  

Reliance on key international trade fairs  

A significant proportion of the Group's sales are made at international trade fairs, and in particular the major fairs. If these fairs were to be discontinued it would have a material effect on the ability of the Group to sell its stock. There are a limited number of stands at international trade fairs and as a result places are highly sought after. Whilst members of the Group have been exhibiting at these fairs for many years, there can be no certainty that they will continue to secure places in the future.  

Competition  

The market in the books and other items in which the Group trades is competitive. In the market for rare books and other items in which Shapero Rare Books trades, the Group faces various competitive pressures including from the major auctioneers, Sotheby's, Christie's, Bonhams and Stanley Gibbons and Spink as well as smaller auctioneers and a large number of dealers and smaller operators.  

The Group is likely to face continued and/or increased competition in the future both from established competitors and/or from new entrants to the market. The Group's competitors include businesses with greater financial and other resources than the Group. Such competitors may be in a better position than the Group to compete for future business opportunities. If the Group is unable to compete effectively in any of the markets in which it operates, it could lead to material adverse effect on the Group's business, financial condition, and operations.  

Co-owned rare and collectible goods  

In the case of high value items or collections, the Group will often acquire the items jointly with another third party bookseller or dealer and if not expressly provided for there is a risk that the Group will not be able to sell the entire asset without the agreement of all joint-owners. In this and other respects the Group relies on the honesty and integrity of other dealers. Whilst the Group takes care to deal only with established counterparties and experienced dealers who are well known to senior management and/or the Directors, there can be no guarantee that co-owners will comply with the agreed terms (including, for example not changing the items) or that such co-owners will not enter into administration or other insolvency procedure, and in the event there is a loss of the co-owned goods it is not certain that the Group could claim under its insurance policy in relation thereto.  

Stock valuation and liquidity  

The Group will trade in rare and collectible items, which may be highly illiquid. The value of goods acquired is difficult to assess and it may not be possible for the Group to sell the assets at or above the price for which they were acquired. The value of assets in the balance sheet may not always represent the actual resale value achievable.  

Theft, loss or damage  

Rare and collectible items are highly mobile goods. Furthermore, such goods are frequently transported internationally for trade shows or other marketing opportunities. Whilst precautions are taken to ensure safe passage, the Group's assets may be lost, damaged or stolen. While the Group carries specialist insurance, there is no guarantee that the Group's insurance cover will be adequate in all circumstances. Assets of the Group will be placed with third parties for sale on commission. While the Group intends to take appropriate precautions when placing assets with third parties, there is a risk that these assets outside of the Group's direct control may be stolen or replaced by unscrupulous third parties with fakes or forgeries.  

Authenticity and export authority  

The Directors of the Group will ensure that due diligence is undertaken on the authenticity of the assets acquired for sale. Nonetheless fakes and forgeries do exist in the market and despite due diligence the Group may acquire these believing them to be authentic. Further, the attribution of works to a writer or artist is not always an exact science, and there can be no guarantee that assets of the Group will not have been mistakenly attributed in this way. Lack of authenticity is not covered by the Group's insurance. Whilst the Group takes appropriate care when acquiring works which may be of material importance in the state of origin, there can be no guarantee that works acquired by the Group are not subject to restrictions on export or sale.  

Insurance  

The Group carries a specialist insurance policy under the Antiquarian Booksellers Association Insurance Scheme which covers each of the businesses. The Directors believe that the Group carries appropriate insurance for a business of its size and nature but there can be no guarantee that the extent or value of the cover will be sufficient, in relation to stock in transit or on consignment. The Directors review the Group's insurance arrangements on an annual basis and endeavour to insure its stock adequately, but there is no certainty that future claims will not fall within the exclusions under the policy or that the insurer will pay out any claim if made. Further, there can be no guarantee that the necessary insurance will be available to the Group in the future at an acceptable cost or at all.  

Premises  

Like many of the established dealers in the market, the Group has a publicly accessible gallery in Mayfair, London from where Shapero Rare Books and Mayfair Philatelics operate. Although there is a risk that the increasing demand for online retail will render 'high street' premises uneconomic, the Directors believe that a central London location is an important factor in the success of the business as a whole.  

Terms of sale  

To date, the contractual arrangements which the Group has entered into with clients, customers and other dealers have not always included (amongst other things) terms dealing specifically with  

1.   transfer of ownership and risk,  

2.   contract formation,  

3.   price and payment,  

4.   limitations and exclusions of liability, and  

5.   governing law and jurisdiction.  

In light of the foregoing, there can be no guarantee that the Group's arrangements with its customers will not be terminated on short notice or that the Group will not at some future time face challenges or disputes in relation to the contractual or other arrangements with its clients.  

If the Group became involved in a contractual dispute and/or a third party was successful in any contractual dispute with the Group, any resultant loss of revenues or exposure to litigation costs or other claims could have a material adverse effect on the Group's reputation, business, financial condition and/or operations or financial results. The Group has revised its standard terms of sale to seek to ensure that, henceforth, the arrangements with clients, customers, dealers and others will include terms dealing with each of the aforementioned areas.  

Employees 

The Group is reliant on a small number of key employees for their knowledge and the reliance customers place on their integrity and service.  In the event that a key employee were to leave, the business may suffer a short term decrease in performance whilst it adjusts to the level of resources available to it. 

Currency risk  

The Directors anticipate that the Group will conduct certain of its transactions other than in Pounds Sterling, the Group's functional currency. As a result, movements in foreign exchange rates may impact the Group's performance. The Group does not enter into any contracts for any hedging arrangements in respect of currency positions.  

Pandemics and government imposed trading restrictions

The Group's trading capabilities are susceptible to the prevalence of pandemics such as Covid 19 which has resulted in the closure of the Group's retail premises for three months and the cancellation of all fairs and exhibitions, together with restrictions on the mobility of its staff, customers and suppliers. The Group has other avenues to market available to it, including the internet, telephone and post, but it may be difficult for the  Group to trade profitably while such a pandemic is present.

Future prospects 

As a result of the restrictions imposed by the UK government in response to Covid 19, the Group is presently loss making. Sales revenues have, however, increased in June and July 2020.

The core business of Shapero Rare Books is one of the leading rare book dealers, with a solid international customer base. Further attention will be required in order to improve its return on capital employed, particularly stock turnover. The board has implemented several online initiatives to manage this.  

Scholium Trading has an established position with several other dealers, and In addition, the current stock includes some items with potentially high levels of return. The board intends to increase the capital available to this business, as the returns over the last 24 months have been good.  

Mayfair Philatelics now has a full year's auction programme in place, and now requires one further expert in due course to maximise the potential from these sales. 

The board continues with its review the opportunity for making further cost savings, with a view to improving the Group's profitability and thereby creating improved shareholder value. As part of this process, the Group has decided to relocate its retail bookshop to lower cost premises during the course of the year ending 31 March 2021.